Thursday, June 21, 2012

No Country For Women

So much has been said about women's rights over the years. Feminists, the women's lib movement, and human rights organizations have all been working tirelessly towards achieving a status of equal importance, dignity and respect for women in society.

India, unfortunately, has a long way to go. The results of a recent poll of G-20 countries conducted by TrustLaw, a legal news service by Thomson Reuters, show that India is the worst country to be a woman. We rank right at the bottom, just below Saudi Arabia.

So many female children are killed even before they are born. Female foeticide has assumed alarming proportions. As per the 2011 Census figures, the country's average sex ratio stands at 940 women per 1,000 men. The child sex ratio (0-6 years) is 914, as compared to 927 in 2001, and is the lowest since independence. 

For many girls who escape abortion and are brought into this world, life is no easy journey. From the time they're born till the time they die, their decisions are made by men. First, the father. Then, the husband. And finally, the son.

In so many Indian homes, daughters' education is relegated to the backseat as they "ultimately have to get married, manage household chores, and look after their husbands and in-laws". A career and financial independence is not an option for many. It is this state of total dependence that makes women highly vulnerable to domestic violence and subjugation in their marital homes. A victim of domestic violence may leave her husband and return to her family, but is (more often than not) compelled to go back to him. Divorce is not looked upon favourably. "Your husband's home is your home now, you must adjust there and live with whatever happens. You can't divorce him, what will people say?" is a stand taken by many girls' families.

Financial burden and dowry are said to be the biggest causes of female foeticide in our country. Daughters are expensive. They're not going to add to the family's income, and prospective grooms will demand a large price as dowry. It doesn't stop after marriage. So many women are subjected to physical and mental torture; some are even killed by greedy husbands and/or in-laws whose demands never end. According to a report by the Times of India, 8,391 women lost their lives over dowry in 2010, which works out to one dowry death every hour. Another recent report by the Financial Times states that only about 18% of dowry deaths result in conviction.

There are plenty of laws against rape and violence, but if women are molested, society blames them for dressing or behaving provocatively. A rape victim is subjected to humiliation right from the time she files a complaint with the cops, to the archaic medical examination she must undergo to "prove" rape, right up to the courtroom drama. It doesn't end after that, either, she is likely to face difficulty in finding a husband. Marital rape is so common, yet the chances of an abused wife getting justice are slim, even though it carries a 2-year prison sentence and/or fine.

Then, you read about honour killings every other day in the newspaper, about young women being murdered by their families for eloping and marrying out-of-caste, or having a relationship which the family does not approve of. Men can be victims too, but a daughter's or sister's 'unapproved' relationship apparently brings more dishonour to the family, as most of the reported murders seem to be of women, or the young men they elope with.

What's unfortunate is that, in so many instances, women are their own worst enemies. In a society where mothers are primarily responsible for their children's upbringing, it is the woman who brings up her son as a chauvinist, who puts him on a higher pedestal than a daughter. A lot of expectant mothers are party to female foeticide. It is the mother-in-law who holds the worst reputation among the in-law clan, for making the daughter-in-law's life difficult (and sometimes, vice versa!). When dowry is being demanded, when brides are being tortured or killed over it, are the mother-in-law and/or sister-in-law not usually active participants?

Aamir Khan's show 'Satyamev Jayate' has revealed some shocking facts, the worst of all being that these horrors are fairly common within educated and urban families too. It isn't just the illiterate and/or low-income strata that is responsible. Indian society largely does not support women. 

It does seem then, that ours is no country for women. Is there hope? I don't know. Yet there are plenty of Indian families which give equal importance and love to daughters, sisters, and wives. Let us, the younger generation be the change. Let us put the enlightenment that education brings to good use, and make India a happier and safer place for the fairer sex.

Text © 2012 http://e-pinion.blogspot.in

74 comments:

  1. You know Ash, while every fact that you have written--from why women don't divorce because of cultural taboos to how women are blamed for their rapes is true.
    And yet, I do not agree women's situation is as bad as the West makes out. I am saying this as a feminist who went on a self-imposed exile in the West for many years and hated everything Indian. Women in west often don't succeed in being feminine anymore. They suffer from immense loneliness. Rape has not decreased. I had a student whose sister was brutally raped and burnt close to her college campus. The founder of the women's resource centre at my univ was raped by footballers.
    Here in India women don't give women as much freedom and men gossip too much. Men's gossip is horrible while women's judgement suffocating. We need to revisit the indexing thing, I believe.
    Anyway this is how I am reading the situation. I am, of course, open to correction.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I see your point Bhavana, rape and violence do happen in other countries, perhaps even more than here. But in the West, I haven't heard of women being taken to task for having 'provoked' such abhorrent violence.

      That's the difference. While crime and abuse against women is a global phenomenon, one can't deny that victims are treated very unfairly here.

      Although, yes, I admit I am surprised we are behind Saudi Arabia (have you read the "Princess" series by Jean Sasson?)

      I didn't get your bit on indexing, can you clarify what that meant? :)

      Delete
    2. Agree with you on that, Ash:"one can't deny that victims are treated very unfairly here." Yes, it is horrible here. But it is bad there too. Rape crisis centre used to teach women (before they got raped) on where to seek medical examination after crime because several times results are lost or contaminated and the rapist goes scott free. Sometimes the woman cannot afford a good lawyer and the court appointed one maybe no match to the lawyer who represents the footballer!

      Yes, I have read the Princess, Ash and it sent shivers down my spine...
      Indexing is how various countries are ranked based on certain set of criteria that always originates from the West. The criteria are not only culturally biased but also evaluated keeping western standards in mind. Basically many of these standard work to make either N.America or Europe look good--PR purposes to promote tourism. I have seen the inside rot in those countries so I don't get jazzed by index ratings. But then again, this is me! I maybe wrong...

      Delete
    3. No, you have a fair point bhavana. The west may tend to hype up what goes on elsewhere. Nevertheless, our country still has a long, long way to go as far as women's position in society is concerned. And it is us, the current generation of women AND MEN, that can kickstart this change. I'm hoping that in another 4-5 decades, the situation will be different :)

      Delete
  2. Very valid points you have mentioned... true, India is bad for women!
    Today, in the evening, we are going for a wedding function of a friend... the girl is in Rajasthan Forest Services (RAS Officer, who passed the RAS exams and the grueling training with flying colours, is smart and beautiful, has all the govt. facilities (a bunglow of her own, guard, servants etc and is earning well). She is getting married to an IAS officer and they have asked for a dowry of 10 lakhs with all the household items, gold etc! Its outrageous!! People are not ashamed of asking dowry and people comply too!! :|

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh dear. That's not good. It is also up to the girl's family to say no to dowry. They have the option to do so.

      Delete
  3. Hi Ash

    Very good post and you have kind of summarized all the evils against women in our society...Except for rape the rest of these are inter-linked....Demand for dowry leads to torture of daughter-in-laws and the same thing causes female foeticides....Things have improved in quite a few communities in the country and I am sure that within another fifty to sixty years things will improve in other communities as well...After all me and you are Indian women and are we not boldly writing our views here?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Absolutely.... And taking/giving dowry is illegal... It is a punishable offence with imprisonment up to 5 years. How can an IAS officer (The enforcer of civic laws)can ask for it and how can one RAS officer accept it?

      Delete
    2. I agree with Jaish... In West Bengal at least among educated people the groom's side is subjected to ridicule if they ask for dowry... Slowly things will change everywhere...

      Delete
    3. I sincerely hope so, jaish :) I sincerely hope things will improve as the new generation takes over...

      I really hope so, rajrupa. It's up to our generation to lead the change.

      Delete
  4. Very grim facts..we don't realize that for our talks about women's emancipation and liberation, it remains just hogwash. Nothing worth mentioning is coming out of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True.... most of it is a lot of window dressing.

      Delete
  5. A very sad reflection of the way our society treats women in general. I too had read that report of Trust law and it paints a very grim picture indeed!Well written!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! I myself was quite shocked to see us behind Saudi Arabia. From what I've read, the women there are treated quite shockingly. Can't drive, can't step out without a man in tow, have to wear covering dresses in public, can't travel without the permission of a man, etc.

      Delete
  6. We need to ebring education to everyone..And if you see the people responsible for this you will find that most of time, women are exploited by other women only...so if only women could stand up and begin to be fair in life, everything will change...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree 100%, Renu ji... this is a very good point. Women do need to stand by women, and be fair to each other.

      Delete
  7. Till the time women themselves do not understand that in this male dominated society we need to stand together, the chances of improving the stature of women in society is bleak.
    Education hardly makes a difference. I have seen educated, independent women are also victims of all these crimes :( A good support system has to be there which will not look down on women but give her an equal status.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True, women need to become friends with each other first :)

      Delete
  8. very well written...i agree with that fact that women are their worst enemies.... most of the times, they force themselves into feeling inferior to men, and we are seeing the result in our society...

    following you!
    http://theduskyindianbeauty.blogspot.in/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ritu... indeed, a lot of women do need to change their mindsets and stop cutting each other out!

      Following you too!

      Delete
  9. Such bare faced truths penned down with such strength! Its a shame when education backfires at certain cases!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Actually, I was quite taken aback to hear on SMJ that all this happens in educated homes too. What a waste of education!

      Delete
  10. Wow... I really did not know that. We still have so long to go :(

    ReplyDelete
  11. ds is an mazing post dat u ve written !! hats off..loved it!! ds is a hard true fact of life!! gr8 wrk :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks palak, these facts are definitely worrisome.

      Delete
  12. Replies
    1. Thanks, will respond soon!

      Delete
  13. Very well written.

    In India, the difference between “haves” and “have nots” and rich and poor are huge. At the same time women are suffering in India, we are able to elect a woman Prime Minister and a woman President. Always the rich wins.

    I agree with the dowry issues. But our family had the opposite experience. My parents and my brother (who is also living in USA) refused any dowry when he got married. The prospective brides’ parents started to doubt us as to why we refuse dowry. May be the boy is already married in USA. May be the boy has some physical problems. Etc. Etc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's quite sad to hear. Girls' families should be the first ones to say a big no.

      Delete
  14. Lack of opportunity--educational and that of free choice in matters of career and love--decidedly put people at a disadvantage. I think the biggest hurdle to overcome is societal mindset--there can be laws on the books to protect women, but until women are truly valued in the minds of their neighbors, rape and abuse will continue.

    As a Westerner, I can say that we don't have all the answers, either. Women here have much more freedom and protection than what you describe here, but yet there is rape and abuse. Often, at least here, some women remain in abusive relationships because they haven't learned to value themselves enough to seek an out. That self-limiting behavior is evidence that on some level, we too don't value women as much as we should or yet truly consider them equal to men. If we, as a society, did, we would instill in out little girls a strength and solid sense of self that helps them to grow into women who don't choose abusive men and if they mistakenly did, would be able to walk away.

    Excellent piece, Ash. I'm your newest follower.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well said. Thanks for following :) I like your blog too!

      Delete
  15. Being a woman I could feel the emotions, Ash. I am aure we shall see a better and a brighter tomorrow....Amen!
    'Women are women's enemies" ah...you couldn't have said it better !
    A wonderful article that reveals the hypocricies so well.
    Very well penned...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you :) I do hope we women can make tomorrow better.

      Delete
  16. wow..wat a great post..
    wonderful future is awaiting for women with their
    improving literacy percentage..
    new to your space
    very interesting space you have ash..
    happy following you..:)
    do stop by mine sometime
    Tasty Appetite

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jay :) glad to have you here!

      Delete
  17. AWesome post!!! No country of women title itself is very powerful. As you said yes it will take a long time to educate everyone!!! i wish it happens sooner!

    And Yes atleast all these are lesson to women to be independent and learn facts of life and be ready for any challenge!!!

    Great post!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ramya.... I hope the change we need comes sooner than later!

      Delete
  18. very well written. Its saddening to see such deplorable state of Indian women.
    These articles/shows and the like efforts, needless to say have made a mark in creating awareness. But its also true that such efforts are fruitful only when some concrete steps are taken in this direction. There has to be a change in the mindset of ppl & for this parents can play an influential role by grooming their children both girls and boys for that matter, right from the beginning.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Quite correct. Parents need to teach all the right things to their kids, whether sons or daughters.

      Delete
  19. Very well written, and patriarchy is going to make the world go to hell. Did you know, that matriarchal societies only exist on paper? In practice, the authority is usually exercised by the oldest woman's brother or nephew. Ridiculous.
    The more aware we are, the better.
    Your posts get better and better :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks kid :) I don't subscribe to patriarchy either.

      Delete
  20. Anonymous8:30 pm

    Great read!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Abhimanyu8:38 pm

    Well written, and you managed to bring out good points. Nice.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Crazy isnt it... While all other country seems to move ahead and become more broad minded, we are going backwards. I am stilling hoping that it will change for better soon

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope so too Ajeya!

      Delete
  23. It is important that women do a paying job. Financial independence is not only important for the women, but also helps in changing the perception of others. I have seen workers in the factories manufacturing IT products (computers, phones etc) earning more then their parents. And that has resulted in their family as well neighbours looking upto these women for suggestions. Remember, I am talking about one meal a day families. So a class 10th or class 12th pass girl earning 5000 odd rupees is more than her fathers salary. If you visit any of the homes of these workers working in the factories in Sriperumbudur (40 kms from chennai) belt, then you will realise the massive impact employment has on changing perception about women. No amount of women empowerment programs can help in achieving this.

    We have to ensure that all the women start earning. There is no doubt about that. I am not sure that this can reduce violation of a women's dignity. However, it can sure reduce the problems of female foeticide.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Its a different topic that how women sustain in male dominated corporate Job :))

      Delete
    2. Bang on! I always advise all my women friends and relatives to take their education seriously, find themselves a sustainable job, and be financially independent. Dependence is an open invitation for exploitation and abuse. Financial independence is critical to self-empowerment.

      Delete
  24. Of course there's hope! Women like us will bring up our daughters differently. Make the feel cherished and tell them that sky is not the limit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True, Purba. But are women like us too few and far between? That's what worries me!

      Delete
  25. Well said there is more to do for women in India ....indeed much more to do ...
    Its very hard to do stand for self in this country ....you always have to prove extra mile and its not easy being women ....
    its sadden to hear so many harassment cases and many women keep quiet for the sake of society ...
    I feel smetime ,women themselve are creating the situation for themselve by not voicing out what their basic needs are ..
    Hope programs like Satya meva jayathe and blogs like urs will create that little awareness in this country :)
    Good read and keep it up

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Women are their own worst enemies....! Lets hope the likes of us can make at least some change :)

      Delete
  26. I'm speechless after reading this post of yours. It deals with such powerful issues, ones that have rocked our society since time immemorial. Hats off to you for having compiled such a moving and educative post. When I ended up reading it, I was sure that you've spoken for so many women out there, and I got reiterated when I saw the large number of female readers that have left words of appreciation. Magnificent work Ash. Keep it up. I'm glad I read this post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much, Anupam... glad you liked it. Thanks for following, too.... look forward to more visits from you!

      Delete
  27. I do agree that women are women's biggest enemies , I mean I hear so many cases of mother in laws doing this and that to DIL.. why it happens i dont know

    what makes me angry and sad is that in our great nation we are more of TALK people, if you know what i mean , seldom anything happens. I also beleive that it will require EACH one of us together to stand hand in hand and work together for all the problems to get away ..

    Bikram's

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True Bikram.... people like us have to be the change.

      Delete
  28. yes theres still hope :) if people like you and me keep on the fight things will will definitely change ... but I loved your post ...you have brought a bitter truth forward ...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks TTT .... I really hope so!

      Delete
  29. You've summed up the issues superbly. Most of these issues will diminish if our method of parenting changes - and we start treating children as individuals and focus on bringing them up as decent human beings - instead of 'training' them to be a good 'future' wife or a good 'investment' when it comes to a son. But I know this is a simplistic statement, and a lot of changes have to take place in parallel at an individual level, society level and political level.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know.... mindsets are not easy to change!

      Delete
  30. Thought provoking post. it is nice, that people are waking up to the problem. May our tribe increase. Loved the post. I've written about the same issue- :)

    http://siahwrites.blogspot.in/2012/07/change-in-your-attitude-could-help-no.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. May our tribe increase, and fast!

      Read your post, its really nice.

      Delete
  31. Did I miss commenting on this one? Because I had read it. You have brilliantly portrayed the distress women face in this country. What must we do, Ash? Look at these terrible incidents happening around us :(.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know Rachna... its a pity... we can at least start by treating our daughters right, I suppose...

      Delete
  32. Wonderfully written Ash. Infact you have raised all the things that have been ringing in my mind since last few days. Women are really repressed here and the future also seems bleak.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope things look up sometime soon :(

      Delete
  33. I just got to read your post after you had left the comment on my post 'Guwahati's shame or India's'. Here's my take on it: The day our men (now amended to read: and women) start treating females as one of their own, as an equal, as a human instead of an object or a form of sating one’s sexual desires is the day we would truly celebrate Women’s Day. You might want to read a similar take here.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Nice blog.very well researched content expressed well.keep up the good work !!

    ReplyDelete

Go on, tell me what you think!